When you watch a graphic birth video, you are met with a plethora of ‘ohs, ‘ews, and ‘ughs’. Some viewers’ jaws drop and their heads recoil in grimaces. Filmmakers ask one participant if he was traumatized, to which he replies ‘definitely.’ The participants then proceed to watch the next birthing video, without being able to see the actual footage.
Unusual home births
While giving birth in the comfort of your own home may sound appealing, it’s not for everyone. You should seek medical advice and consider your proximity to a hospital before choosing this option. Alternatively, giving birth in a hospital can be a beautiful experience, as well. Luckily, many famous mothers have chosen this method. In addition to giving birth in their own homes, celebrities like Ashley Graham and Jessica Alba have also opted for this type of delivery.
The study’s results came under fire from the midwifery community, which denounced it as an attempt to discredit the home birth movement. In addition, the data for home births comes from observational studies, which can be flawed due to misclassification of birth outcomes. Because of these problems, vital facts cannot be compared. The study’s authors cite the example of Dr. Ellen Tilden, an assistant professor at the Oregon Health and Science University.
Effects of graphic births on participants
Graphic birth videos have many drawbacks, not least of which is the potential to cause participants distress. Contrary to popular belief, the process of childbirth is not as painless as those portrayed in youtube videos. The actual experience of giving birth is uncomfortable, and the pain isn’t just in the womb. It can even be harmful to the baby if the video contains scenes of a painful or traumatic childbirth.
The study compared women who gave birth at home with those who had a conventionally attended birth in an obstetric unit. The researchers used an obstetric unit to determine if the risk of complications was higher among women who choose home birth. They adjusted for the mothers’ age, race, and various sociodemographic characteristics. The results showed that women who gave birth at home were older, white, and better educated than their counterparts who chose a freestanding midwifery center.